Stanford University Courses starting soon...(and disappoint me)

Hey all!
I subscribed to Crypto-Course at the Stanford U. and watched the first 2 lession...then i decided to quit it and wait for the Udacity Course on Crypto, because:

  • Stanford courses seems very impersonal compared to the Udacity courses
  • Stanford shows a slide after the other (powerpoint imo) in too long video lectures (10-25min)
  • The lecture slides (pdf) are a bit prettier but are exactly the same as seen in the video lecture without further comments etc.
  • You have to understand english well enough to keep up in Stanford classes

...hope Udacity stays the way it is ;)

asked 07 Mar '12, 03:14

Daniel%20Winter's gravatar image

Daniel Winter
1.2k1218
accept rate: 20%


8 Answers:

I don't like it either. Udacity style is better, it keeps my attention. I just hope they will cover other topics like computer vision.

link

answered 07 Mar '12, 05:42

Milana%20%C5%A0panovi%C4%87's gravatar image

Milana Španović
8142924

I've been really impressed by the first unit of the Design and Analysis of Algorithms class - The instructor, Tim Roughgarden is a very effective lecturer and the videos don't seem to suffer the same quality issues that drove me away from SaaS.

link

answered 07 Mar '12, 07:09

James%20Holyhead's gravatar image

James Holyhead
3.0k51632

Thumbs up for Design and Analysis, I really like the instructor too!

(08 Mar '12, 10:40) George Brind... George%20Brindeiro's gravatar image

Well, I'm not sure if the issues you mention are pluses or minuses. They all indicate that the recordings are taken straight out from their on-campus lectures. This means we receive the same treatment, getting the same materials as on-campus students. I always fear that on-line classes are ways too inferior to on-campus classes. (that was the case for last year Machine Learning class)

link

answered 07 Mar '12, 04:28

avxV's gravatar image

avxV
7634822

1

I've actually had the opposite experience, looking at for example the SAAS class. The video provided chops off the right hand edge of the slides making them hard to read, and a lot of code is rendered at a font so small that the video just fails to capture it. I just get the feeling that classes like that often treat the online learners as second class citizens. Granted, that may be fair, as we're not exactly PAYING for the lectures!

Meanwhile, the slides published have errors such as text fields covering other text fields making them challenging to read. I like the personal feel that the Stanford classes developed, especially after spending a fair time with the MIT Open Courseware lectures (which ARE awesome, for the record.)

(07 Mar '12, 04:33) xyzzy-2 xyzzy-2's gravatar image

It seems like each professor uses the Coursera platform as he likes, not necessarily following the db-class/ml-class (very successful, as I see them) format.

(07 Mar '12, 04:38) jimgb-2 jimgb-2's gravatar image

I agree that the videos in standford's "coursera" are too long, but the new pages with the lectures both in video and text are great, the text option is good for who spends long time without connection to the internet.
The bright side is that even you don't follow the classes, you will have access to the material

link

answered 07 Mar '12, 04:36

martimorta's gravatar image

martimorta
12

I do agree about all the above notes, but it would be great for people like us with limited (Time=cost) Internet connection to have a downloadable (edited: it takes just one piece of code ) full vid of each unit along with the .Pdf notes, this way we can :

  1. Download the 2hours (vid+ the pdf )
  2. Work on them offline :)
  3. Post the homework and programming assignment
link

answered 07 Mar '12, 04:47

Haroun's gravatar image

Haroun
6302714

In addition to what have been said, I did touch that sparkle in Stanford courses (Except for Prof. Andrew Ng.) as I felt in the courses of Prof Thrun and Udacity lectures. You can tell that by attending one lecture that they will do it once and quit it.

link

answered 07 Mar '12, 05:59

Abdalrahman%20Eweiwi's gravatar image

Abdalrahman ...
622

I think we should be really really grateful having such a great teacher in this class and a great site with quizzes with a sort of feedback loop, fantastic videos and a team (Andy,..) that is always there to respond to any issues!

I would not like to see a powerpoint presentation. This class here is far superior!!

link

answered 07 Mar '12, 06:41

Dietmar%20Peglow's gravatar image

Dietmar Peglow
1.4k81727

I think the overall difference for me is, while Udacity is more personal and has shorter lectures, Coursera (at least the Design and Analysis of Algorithms Class) seems to cover each topic in more depth and require more effort and background from the student. It's working for me!

link

answered 08 Mar '12, 10:41

George%20Brindeiro's gravatar image

George Brind...
8.1k165298

Your answer
Question text:

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "Title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "Title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Tags:

×5,207
×644
×93
×12

Asked: 07 Mar '12, 03:14

Seen: 753 times

Last updated: 08 Mar '12, 10:41